Which Deck is Right for You?

A deck is the main character of your backyard space. It is the hub for family socialization through get-togethers, cooking out, or just enjoying the evening air. A classic deck is made of various options suiting your personal preference and your homes personal style.

Choosing between Cedar, Pressure-Treated, or Composite Decking can be challenging. But let’s simplify it so you know the difference! Also, a suitable deck will increase the value of your home.

Though all types can make excellent options, only one of them is right for your space. Here are the advantages and disadvantages of each:

Cedar Deck

Natural wood decks (typically Cedar) are popular with many homeowners because they are aesthetically pleasing and an attractive bonus for those who prefer a natural wood deck.

Advantages:

1. Beautiful natural wood with an organic appearance. Cedar also accepts and holds a variety of stains well.
2. Cedar is naturally resistant to rot, decay, and fungus.
3. Because moisture warps, bends, and rots wood, cedar is more likely to resist problems and hold up longer than pressure treated.
4. Cedar warps and twists less than other wood. It also shrinks less.
5. Going barefoot. Cedar is softer underfoot and stays cooler than pine.

Disadvantages:

1. The natural hue fades if not routinely sealed.
2. It is more likely to be scratched when furniture is moved around due to its softer nature.
3. Low-lying, ground-level, or constantly shaded decks can deteriorate faster because they dry out slower.
4. Cedar requires regular maintenance.
5. On average. Cedar decking will cost twice as much as treated decking.

‍

Pressure Treated Deck

Pressure-treated wood southern yellow pine that undergoes a chemical treatment process to increase resistance to rot and insect damage.

Many homeowners consider a pressure treated deck as the best option because of the following:

Advantages:

1. The number one reason pressure treated is chosen over other option is cost.
2. Can be stained to a desired color or the stain color changed if you want something different over time.
3. Has an extended life expectancy due to the chemical treatment.
4. It's more resilient to water and insect damage than untreated wood.
5. Pressure-treated wood works well for ground level and low-lying decks.

Disadvantages:

1. The chemicals used for pressure treatment are harmful to the environment.
2. Pressure-treated lumber can withstand moisture and decay, but it can crack and dry out in hot and dry weather. It is less resilient to the Midwest climate changes.
3. It also dries and twists unevenly due to the woods inherent tendency to retain moisture.
4. The biggest disadvantage to pressure treated wood is the upkeep. While they can last up to 30 years, they must be maintained regularly. A sealer should be applied once a year, stain every 2 years, and pressure washed twice a year.

‍

Composite Deck

Low-maintenance composites are a common selling point, and for a good reason; they are an excellent alternative for homeowners who don't care about the natural appearance.

Composite decking uses recycled plastic, wood chips, and other natural materials like bamboo. It can be both eco-friendly and a beautiful alternative to other decking options.

Advantages :

1. It's well-protected from the elements and only needs minor cleaning to preserve its look.
2. Variety of colors and options available, such as, UV protection, non-slip texture, and scratch resistance.
3. Composite decks get better in appearance daily.
4. Hidden fasteners are commonly used so no visible screw holes.
5. Composite decking is impermeable to water and will not rot or decay. Bugs also have zero interest in it as well.
6. With a wide variety of color options, the color and design choice is limitless.

Disadvantages:

1. Cost is the most deterring factor to composite decking.
2. Composite decking is not designed to be structural and pressure treated or cedar is still used for the bones of the decking.  
3. It can melt from hot cooking grease or grilling. And single board replacement is more difficult due to the hidden fasteners.
4. Warranties vary by manufacturer. Always choose a product that has a stain and fade warranty.
5. In direct sun, the boards can become hot to the touch.

‍

Every home should have a suitable deck that fits the lifestyle of the family and their tastes. It is advisable to consult with your contractor for advice on what is right for you. We would be happy to discuss these option with you as well as discuss what an investment like this might cost.

‍